212-227-8877
Tacopina Seigel & DeOreo - Criminal Lawyers in NYC
  • Attorneys
    • Joseph Tacopina
    • Chad Seigel
    • Matthew Deoreo
    • Eleonora Maria Lanzone
    • Of Counsel
      • Sara Azari
  • Practice Areas
    • Criminal Law
    • Civil Litigation
  • Notable Cases
  • Firm Overview
  • Featured Press
  • Media
    • TV Appearances
    • Radio Mentions
    • International Press
    • In The News
    • Thought Leadership

The Biggest Mistakes People Make After Being Arrested in New York

By Joseph Tacopina Published September 2, 2026
Criminal Defense

Being arrested in New York can be one of the most stressful experiences a person will ever face. Whether the arrest involves a misdemeanor, felony, DUI, assault, theft, or another criminal allegation, the decisions you make immediately afterward can have a lasting impact on your case.

Many people unknowingly make mistakes that weaken their defense before they even speak with a lawyer. Understanding what to avoid can help protect your rights and improve your ability to build a strong legal strategy.

At Tacopina Seigel & DeOreo – Criminal Lawyers in NYC, we have represented individuals throughout New York City, including Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx, and Staten Island. If you are searching for the best criminal defense attorney trusted by New York City residents, knowing what to do-and what not to do-after an arrest is the first step.

Why Your Actions After an Arrest Matter

After an arrest, every conversation, social media post, and decision can potentially affect your case. Prosecutors may use statements, digital evidence and witness testimony when building their arguments.

An experienced criminal defense attorney can help protect your constitutional rights, evaluate the evidence and develop a defense strategy tailored to your circumstances.

1. Talking to Police Without a Lawyer

One of the most common mistakes is trying to explain your side of the story without legal representation.

Many people believe that cooperating fully will resolve the situation quickly. Unfortunately, even innocent explanations may later be misunderstood or used against you.

Instead:

  • Politely exercise your right to remain silent.
  • Request an attorney immediately.
  • Avoid answering investigative questions until your lawyer is present.

2. Waiting Too Long to Hire a Criminal Defense Attorney

Time matters after an arrest.

The earlier your attorney becomes involved, the sooner they can:

  • Review the evidence
  • Protect your legal rights
  • Communicate with prosecutors
  • Preserve important witness statements
  • Identify weaknesses in the prosecution’s case

3. Discussing Your Case with Friends or Family

Many people assume conversations with friends, coworkers, or acquaintances are private.

They are not.

Anyone you speak with could later become a witness if necessary.

Limit discussions about your case to your attorney, whose communications are protected by attorney-client privilege.

4. Posting About Your Arrest on Social Media

Social media has become a valuable source of evidence in criminal cases.

Avoid posting:

  • Photos
  • Videos
  • Comments
  • Location check-ins
  • Opinions about the arrest
  • Conversations regarding your case

Even deleted content may still be recoverable.

5. Ignoring Court Dates or Legal Deadlines

Missing a required court appearance can create additional legal complications.

Always:

  1. Know your scheduled court dates.
  2. Follow your attorney’s guidance.
  3. Arrive prepared and on time.
  4. Bring any requested documents.

6. Assuming Every Criminal Case Is the Same

No two criminal cases are identical.

Factors such as:

  • Evidence
  • Witness testimony
  • Prior legal history
  • Police procedures
  • Constitutional issues
  • Local court practices

can all influence the outcome.

7. Choosing a Lawyer Based Only on Online Ratings

Online research is important, but it should never be the only factor when selecting legal representation.

While reading New York criminal lawyer reviews can provide useful insights, also consider:

Experience

Look for attorneys who regularly defend criminal cases in New York courts.

Courtroom Skills

Not every case settles before trial. Trial experience can be an important factor.

Communication

Your attorney should clearly explain legal options and keep you informed throughout your case.

Local Knowledge

Attorneys familiar with New York judges, prosecutors, and court procedures understand how local systems operate.

These are important considerations when asking, how do I choose a criminal defense lawyer in New York?

8. Underestimating DUI Charges

Many people believe a DUI arrest is a routine legal matter.

However, DUI cases often involve:

  • Chemical testing procedures
  • Field sobriety evidence
  • Police reports
  • Constitutional issues
  • Administrative hearings

How an Experienced NYC Criminal Defense Attorney Can Help

An experienced defense lawyer can:

  • Review police procedures
  • Challenge improperly obtained evidence
  • Protect your constitutional rights
  • Negotiate with prosecutors when appropriate
  • Prepare a strong courtroom defense
  • Guide you through every stage of the legal process

Why Local Experience Matters in New York City

Criminal cases are handled in courts across NYC, including those serving:

  • Manhattan
  • Brooklyn
  • Queens
  • The Bronx
  • Staten Island

Protect Your Rights After an Arrest

An arrest does not determine the outcome of your case.

The choices you make immediately afterward-and the legal guidance you receive-can have a significant impact on your future.

If you or a loved one has been arrested in New York City, the experienced attorneys at Tacopina Seigel & DeOreo – Criminal Lawyers in NYC are prepared to evaluate your situation, explain your legal options and provide strategic representation throughout the legal process.

Contact Tacopina Seigel & DeOreo today to schedule a confidential consultation and learn how our criminal defense team can help protect your rights.

Frequently Asked Questions

How soon should I contact a criminal defense attorney after being arrested in New York?

You should contact an attorney as soon as possible after your arrest. Early legal guidance helps protect your rights and allows your attorney to begin reviewing the facts of your case immediately.

What should I do if I am arrested in NYC?

Remain calm, exercise your right to remain silent, request an attorney and avoid discussing your case with anyone other than your lawyer.

How do I choose a criminal defense lawyer in New York?

Look for experience handling criminal cases, courtroom experience, knowledge of New York courts, clear communication and a strong professional reputation.

Should I read New York criminal lawyer reviews before hiring an attorney?

Reviews can provide helpful insight into client experiences, but they should be considered alongside the attorney’s experience, qualifications and familiarity with New York criminal courts.

Can a criminal defense attorney help with DWI charges in NYC?

Yes. A criminal defense attorney for DWI in NYC can review the evidence, examine police procedures, identify legal issues and develop a defense strategy based on the specific facts of your case.

footer footer-mobile

Let the best
in the business

defend you.

Call us for a free consultation 24/7

PHONE
212-227-8877
ADDRESS

275 Madison Avenue, 35th Floor,
New York, New York 10016

Background Image Background Image
  • Firm Overview
  • Attorneys
  • Practice Areas
    • Criminal Law
    • Civil Litigation
  • Notable Cases
    • Notable Criminal Cases
    • Notable Civil Cases
  • Media
    • Thought Leadership
    • Featured Press
    • In The News
  • Contact
  • Privacy
  • facebookFacebook
  • twitterTwitter
  • linkedinLinkedIn
  • instagramInstagram
  • lawyersLawyers.com

Tacopina Seigel & DeOreo is located in New York, NY and serves clients in and around New York, Long Island City, Sunnyside, Astoria, Brooklyn, Woodside, Maspeth, Middle Village, Jackson Heights, Elmhurst, Ridgewood, East Elmhurst, Bronx, Rego Park, Corona, Forest Hills, Woodhaven, College Point, Ozone Park, Jamaica, Howard Beach, Bronx County, Kings County, New York County and Queens County.

Attorney Advertising. This website is designed for general information only. The information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship. [ Do Not Sell My Personal Information ]

© 2026 Tacopina Seigel Trial Lawyers
Design by SPINX Digital